Uncovering Hidden Gems: A Thrilling Walking Tour of Historic Sandwich MA!

When it comes to exploring the rich history of Cape Cod, few places can compete with the charm and allure of Sandwich, Massachusetts. As one of the oldest towns in the United States and the oldest town on Cape Cod, Sandwich invites visitors to step back into a time of colonial architecture and fascinating tales. This blog post takes you on an exciting journey through Sandwich, showcasing its most historic sites and hidden gems that are sure to inspire anyone with an appreciation for history.

The Dunbar Tea Room

Our journey begins at the charming 1920's Dunbar Tea Room, located at 1 Water Street. This delightful establishment sits along the scenic Shawme Pond and has become a beloved local spot for both residents and visitors. Not only does it serve a variety of exquisite teas and light fare, but its inviting atmosphere is perfect for relaxing and enjoying the historic surroundings.

In the 1920s, Colonel Henry Dunbar bought the house so he could be close to his supervision of the widening of the Cape Cod Canal. They added the carriage house, a billiard room, tennis court and planted wonderful landscaped rose gardens. During these years Mrs. Dunbar established the tradition of hosting teas in the beautiful rose gardens.

The Dunbar Tea Room has a rich history of its own, once serving as a gathering place for community events. With its period décor and welcoming ambiance, it’s an ideal starting point for your adventure through Sandwich. Hopefully you are starting this tour after a cuppa and delicious lunch!

Dunbar Tea Room in Sandwich, MA.

John Dillingham

The John Dillingham House is a large Georgian house set across Lower Shawme Lake from the Grist Mill at 132 Main Street. John Dillingham (1710-1797) built the house in 1740, and it remained in the Dillingham family until the mid 19th century when it was bought by Anthony Chapouil Jr. (1804-1892). Chapouil came to Sandwich to work for the Boston & Sandwich Glass Company. Abigail Russell Gifford Bicknell (1839-1922), a descendant of Chapouil by marriage, inherited the property in 1900 and operated a tea room in the house. After her death in 1922, the house was purchased by Colonel H. P. Dunbar who renovated the house and constructed the three-bay carriage house.

The town bought the house in 1974 and sold it to a private owner in 1993, with a preservation restriction. It was operated as a B&B, and the carriage house, as mentioned above, is The Dunbar Tea Room. In 2020, the house and the restaurant were divided and are now owned by different individuals.

The First Church of Christ

Just a short stroll from the tea room is the First Church of Christ located at 136 Main Street. More than just a place of worship, this impressive structure is steeped in history. Erected in 1847, it exemplifies Colonial New England architecture, featuring exquisite Gothic windows and a striking steeple.

Elvis church because it was used as a backdrop on Elvis Presley's first gospel album "How Great Thou Art” recorded in 1967. A copy of the album is located in the vestibule of the church.

This church also contains the oldest church bell in Massachusetts and one of the oldest in America. Its origins involve a Captain Adolph de Groot who was shipwrecked and drowned off the coast of Sandwich in 1703. Rev. Cotton found papers on his body and wrote to his wife in NY informing her that her husband had died and was given a Christian burial in town. She was so grateful that she had a bell sent to the parish in thanks and so that her husband could hear the sweet sound from his grave. The bell was cast in Holland in 1675 and is also in the vestibule.

Melitiah Bourne House

Next on our tour is the Melitiah Bourne House at 138 Main Street. This circa 1699-1710 historic home is a beautiful representation of early American architecture, characterized by its distinct gambrel roof and elegant proportions. Named after Melitiah Bourne, an influential figure in Sandwich’s early history, the house captivates with its well-preserved features.

Melitiah Bourne was the wealthiest man in the town during his time. He served as a lawyer, judge, and was a member of the Massachusetts General Court. This house belonged to four generations of the Bourne family, with the last member passing away here in 1862. Pause for a moment to envision the numerous generations that have walked through its doors, connecting the present with Sandwich's history.

Captain Ezra Nye House

A short walk away is the Captain Ezra Nye House at 152 Main Street. This must-see property brings the maritime history of Sandwich to life. Built in 1755 and once inhabited by a local whaling captain, the house stands as a testament to the town's seafaring heritage.

He wed the daughter of innkeeper Fessenden and gifted her a wedding house located across the street, now incorporated into the Dan'l Webster Inn. They resided there briefly before he constructed this larger house directly opposite.

Subsequently, this became the residence of Theodore Kerns, who led the glass cutting operations at the Boston and Sandwich Glass Factory.

H.G.O Ellis House

Continuing our journey along Main Street, we approach the H.G.O. Ellis House at 154 Main Street. This charming house features a side-front door, a spacious front porch, and a bay window. It exemplifies the prosperity brought to the town by the glass industry. Hazel Blake French, an early 20th-century jewelry designer, lived here and incorporated Boston & Sandwich glass fragments into her creations.

Jonathan Leonard House

Just a short distance away, the Jonathan Leonard House at 156 Main Street offers a glimpse into the life of its namesake, a soldier from the Revolutionary War. Dating back to 1740, this preserved home showcases colonial life and the building techniques employed during that era.

And, it has been owned and occupied by somebody named Jonathan Leonard since 1798! Moreover, all 5 generations of Jonathan Leonard's are Harvard graduates.

Quince Tree House

The Quince Tree House located at 164 Main Street is yet another hidden gem worth exploring. Named for the magnificent quince tree that graces its yard, this historic home built in 1842 as a classic Cape Cod architecture with its straightforward lines.

Owned by a glass cutter at the Boston & Sandwich Glass Factory and later by Dr. Samuel Beale (1914-1965) for whom Beale St. was named.

Charles Waterman House

As we continue further along Main Street, we encounter the Charles C.P. Waterman House, a grand structure that reflects Sandwich’s historical aesthetic built1836. Mr. Waterman served as an executive at the Boston & Sandwich Glass Factory with the title of "Paymaster." However, his responsibilities extended beyond this role. Besides managing the payroll for 500 workers, he also collected rents for Jarves and acted as the financial officer for the brick factory and iron works, which had become part of the glass factory's operations. A friend of Jarves, he arrived in 1825 and worked for Mr. Jarves for a total of 44 years.

The house tells the story of its namesake, a noteworthy figure in Sandwich’s history, embodying the elegance that characterized many homes during the town’s earlier days.

Methodist Church

At 175 Main Street, the former Methodist Church, now known as the Masonic Hall, adds to Sandwich's rich tapestry of history. Built in 1847, this building was originally the Methodist Church.

Despite having a population of just 3,000, the town featured Congregational, Unitarian, Episcopal, Methodist, and Catholic churches, along with the Quaker Meeting House.

Isaiah Jones House

Our next stop is the Isaiah Jones House located at 165 Main Street. This historic residence, constructed in 1840, boasts a captivating façade and narrates an intriguing tale of the town’s heritage. This home was originally built by Dr. Jonathan Leonard II in 1840. Notice the side entryway for patients, along with the front and rear entrances for guests and family. In 1861, he sold the house to Isaiah Jones, who owned a tack factory on Shawme Pond. By the late 1880s, Jones became involved in cranberry cultivation and held a position with the Cape Cod Cranberry Growers Association.

It has now been transformed into a charming Victorian B&B, offering luxury suite accommodations in the former barn located at the back of the property.

George Drew House

Continuing on our journey, we arrive at the George Drew House at 8 Jarves Street, built in 1881. Cape Cod Haberdasher George Drew, a wealthy clothing merchant, who had stores in Hyannis and here on Jarves St. It became the rectory for the Catholic Church next door.

This building serves as an excellent example of a 2 1/2-story house with intricate massing, showcasing features of the Queen Anne, Stick, and Gothic Revival styles. It rests on a brick foundation and features synthetic clapboard and decorative-shingle siding, along with an asphalt shingle roof. The house includes a partially restored Second Empire-style cupola with cresting, Stick Style decorative trusses in the gables, diagonal flat stickwork beneath certain windows, Gothic Revival pointed-arched windows, decorative crossbracing, and Queen Anne patterned shingle siding. The facade is elaborate, with carved and bracketed details. It also has two one-story porches, a tower, and dormers. The windows are diverse, many with curved tops. A central entrance is accessible through the front porch, featuring curved-top double doors. It truly is a beautiful site.

Now it is converted into the Next Door Burger Bar restaurant and The Painted Lady Inn owned by Chris Wilson. Outside there are lush gardens and patios with a spacious event lawn invite gatherings and celebrations.

Distinct architectural style of the George Drew House in Sandwich, MA.

Corpus Christi Church

At 8 Jarves Street, the Corpus Christi Church stands as a site rich with spiritual and historical significance. Corpus Christi Church, now the Belfry Inn, was built in 1901. The Church was built in 1901 to replace the St. Peter's Church that was destroyed in a storm in 1898. To begin glass operations, Deming Jarves relocated about 60 skilled workers and their families from Cambridge, MA. They were all Irish and Catholics, a group never seen before in Sandwich. This was a major social change brought about by the B&S operations. By 1830, the Catholics built their own chapel which sat very near the factory.

Currently, it is recognized as The Belfry, a distinguished restaurant and inn owned by Chris Wilson. The Belfry Inn and Bistro delivers exceptional fine dining. Famous for its romantic dining ambiance, this historic location is perfect for couples looking for an intimate meal or a special date night. Additionally, The Belfry Inn and Bistro is a leading choice for Wednesday wine events on Cape Cod, featuring a curated selection of wines that pair beautifully with their exquisite menu.

Puritan Church

A short walk from Corpus Christi brings us to the Puritan Church at 16 Jarves Street built in 1850. This structure initially served as a chapel for individuals who disagreed with the Congregational Church. John Jarves was among its founders, and it later became an Episcopal church. Over time, it has had various uses, including as a USO building during World War II and as a Catholic Youth Organization facility named Father Clinton Hall when owned by the Catholic parish. Observe the cross beneath the awning, indicating its religious heritage.

Now, it is known as Beth's Bakery which serves a wide variety of homemade pastries and goods.

Sandwich Antiques Center

After exploring the local churches and stores, make your way to the Sandwich Antiques Center at the end of Jarvis, 131 MA-6A. This delightful center houses a plethora of unique vintage items that carry their own stories.

Browsing through the eclectic collections can be a treasure hunt of sorts. You might even find the perfect souvenir that adds a piece of Sandwich's history to your collection!

Captain Stutson House

As we head back toward Main Street, do not overlook the Captain William Stutson House, a historic residence built in 1825. This home was owned by Deming Jarves's sister, Sally and her husband. He was the General Manager of the Boston & Sandwich Glass Factory during the early years and Deming often stayed here on his visits to the factory.

With architectural elements reflective of early maritime life, the house is a true nod to the town's rich history.

John Jarves House

Next, we visit the John Jarves House located at 3 Jarves Street built in 1857.

This stunning residence was a wedding gift from Deming to his son John and his new wife, Mary. It was the most costly and contemporary house in the town at that time.

Mary's world seemed perfect. She was married to a wealthy, handsome man and had two children living in the best home in town. But that rapidly changed. In 1863, John died of TB at age 28. The next year her daughter Bertha died and the following year her son Arthur died. At age 26, Mary was a widow and childless.

The well-preserved home offers an intriguing glimpse into the lives and experiences of early Sandwich residents.

Brown Jug

Walking along Main Street, you'll encounter a rich collection of historical sites that contribute to the charm of Sandwich. The Brown Jug at 155 Main Street is a beloved local establishment that symbolizes the spirit of the community. Once a tinware and stove shop that burned to the ground in 1908.

If you're around on the weekends when their wood-fired oven is fired up make sure to stop in for a pizza and glass of wine at their hidden outdoor patio.

Spotted Cow

Nearby, at 153 Main Street, once a 19th century apothecary shop is now The Spotted Cow.

Nancy Fessenden

The 1826 Nancy Fessenden home located at 151 Main Street serves as another remarkable example of Sandwich’s architectural heritage. In 1826, Nancy Freeman Fessenden married Captain Ezra Nye and moved into this new residence after their wedding. Nye was a distinguished sea captain who sailed his clipper ship Amethyst from Liverpool to Boston in a record 20 days in 1829. His most notable achievement came in 1852 when his ship, the Pacific, encountered a sinking packet ship during a gale in the mid-Atlantic, and he successfully rescued all passengers and crew. For this, Queen Victoria awarded him a medal and a gold chronometer.

In 1982, the Dan'l Webster Inn renovated the Nancy Fessenden House to create four luxury suites.

Dan'l Webster

Nancy's grandfather, Rev. Benjamin Fessenden, was the town minister of Sandwich from 1725 to 1746. In 1729, his supporters constructed a house for him at 149 Main Street. After his death, his son William (Nancy's father) transformed the house into the Fessenden Tavern. Ironically, William was a teetotaler. During the Revolution, the tavern became known as a headquarters for the Patriots.

Over the years, the property continued to operate as an inn, undergoing several name changes: Smith’s Tavern, Mansion House, Central House, and finally becoming the Dan'l Webster Inn in 1915. Daniel Webster, a renowned US Senate orator, was a frequent visitor to the area for hunting and fishing. He was such a regular and notable guest that he had a room reserved from 1815 to 1851. The original building was destroyed by fire in 1971, and the current Dan'l Webster Inn was constructed on the same site. You could enjoy a pint at this location for more than 225 years!

Town Hall Annex

The town purchased the former Cooperative Bank building in 1977 relieving pressure at the time to rebuild the interior of the old Town Hall. 145 Main, which later became known as the Town Hall Annex, was vacated in 2023 after the construction of the new town hall.

The building occupies the location once known as the "Boyden Block," owned by William Ellis Boyden. This area featured a lengthy structure with multiple shops and a spacious meeting hall on the upper floor. Additionally, there was a large livery stable where Boyden housed his horses and stagecoaches. Beginning in 1822, he operated a stagecoach service between Plymouth and Sandwich. The Boyden Block was constructed in 1857 by Gustavus Howland, who also built the Boardwalk. Gustavus was the son of Ellis Howland, the builder of Sandwich Town Hall in 1834.

1833 First Parish Church

At 143 Main, the First Parish Church stands. In 1639 this spot was set aside for public use and a thatched-roof Meetinghouse was built. In 1704 it was replaced by a larger, 2-story Meetinghouse. Town meetings were held here and it was also home to a Calvinist/Congregational parish.

The “Old Titus” Clock:

In 1748, Pastor Abraham Williams arrived with a 19-year-old black slave named Titus Winchester. Williams offered Titus his freedom, but Titus chose to wait until his master's death in 1784 to become free. Afterward, Titus went to sea as a steward and, upon his death in 1808, bequeathed his entire estate (around $1,100) to purchase a two-faced clock for the Meetinghouse “so that it would ring for many years to come in memory of his former master.” The clock faces were directed south (toward Main Street) and west (toward River Street). This clock became known as “Old Titus.”

However, the clock you see today is not the original. On a Sunday night in 1873, a malfunction caused the clock to chime 406 times before it stopped. In 1880, a new four-faced clock and a larger spire were installed.

Now transformed into a 7270 sq. ft. home of light-filled luxury owned by local restaurateur Chris Wilson.

Rev. Asahel Cobb

At 141 Main, the 1850 home of Rev. Asahel Cobb. Rev. Asahel Cobb who was a minister in the Calvinist Church until he resigned in 1842. In the early 20th century it included the first small shop in town to sell antique Sandwich glass. The re-appreciation of Sandwich glass began here.

This is currently a private home.

Captain Nichols Home

A short walk from the Reverend's home takes us to the Captain Nicools Home at 139 Main, constructed in 1868. Capt. Nichols was a whaling captain from New Bedford who retired to Sandwich. During the Civil War, many young men learned to play the new game of baseball. Upon returning to Sandwich, they played the first game on Cape Cod in November 1865 on Nichols' property on nearby School Street. In gratitude, they named themselves The Nichols Baseball Club of Sandwich, the first 9-man team on Cape Cod.

This is currently a private home.

Mill Creek Park

Taking a brief respite from historical exploration, we arrive at Mill Creek Park, a serene green space that invites relaxation. This beautiful park offers scenic walking paths that wind through vibrant greenery, providing a lovely spot to reflect on the journey through Sandwich’s past.

The peace and beauty of the area perfectly complement the history that surrounds it, providing an ideal spot for visitors to unwind.

It was redesigned by the Sandwich 375 Anniversary Committee and presented to the town as a legacy gift.

Sandwich Glass Museum

The Sandwich Glass Museum located at 129 Main Street, aims to foster a comprehensive understanding and appreciation of the history of Sandwich town, focusing on the unique impact of the glass industry on the local community, the region, the nation, and the world. Founded by the Sandwich Historical Society in 1907.

Moreover, the Sandwich Glass Museum seeks to explore the modern use of glass as a medium for creating art and fine crafts, connecting contemporary works with historical techniques, and educating the public through exhibitions, presentations, and demonstrations.

Eaton Memorial Park

Located across the street is Eaton Memorial Park. In 1911, William Eaton established it to honor the soldiers and sailors from Sandwich who participated in the Civil War. Sandwich was the first town on Cape Cod to form a military unit. Out of a population of about 3,500, 293 men served, and 54 lost their lives. A Vietnam Memorial was recently added to this park.

Whether you are looking for a leisurely stroll or a deeper understanding of local history, Eaton Memorial Park enhances any Sandwich exploration.

Seth Nye Law Office

The Seth Nye Law Office at 2 Grove Street may not feature grand architectural elements, but its significance in the community is remarkable. Seth Nye was a highly successful lawyer and later served as a judge in the town of Sandwich. His law office was conveniently located next door to the magnificent Federal style house he owned. Notice that the roof line matches that of his home. He had three unmarried sisters who operated a millinery shop, or ladies' hat shop, situated behind the left door. Mr. Nye's office was on the right. As a judge, he presided over numerous cases here, handling minor issues that didn't require a Court House appearance, such as malicious destruction of property and public drunkenness. The trials involved only three people: the judge, the constable presenting the charge, and the defendant. Mr. Nye gained a mention in Ripley's Believe It or Not for stating, "No lawyer could ever justify a fee of $10."

In 1891, this building became the town's first Public Library. It is now a single-family private residence.

Historic Taverns and Inns

First on this road is 6 Grove Street "Bendora" built in 1888. Benjamin Gibbs Bartley built and presented as a gift to his new wife, Theodora Newcomb. They named it “Bendora,” derived from their names: BENjamin and TheoDORA. They were married on October 3, 1888.

As we venture further, we arrive at 8 Grove Street, home to the Newcomb Tavern. Dating back to 1703, this tavern provides an excellent look into the social dynamics of Sandwich throughout centuries. Peter Newcomb, from Edgartown, Martha's Vineyard, operated the town's first tavern and was renowned for his hospitality. The house remains largely as it was originally constructed, with the exception of improvements made to the north side.

At 10 Grove Street, we find the John Dexter/Seth Pope house built in 1699. It is now known in town as the “Russell House.“

Each of these sites offers a window into the daily life of Sandwich’s past residents, enriching the historical experience.

Old Town Burial Ground

No visit to Sandwich is complete without a stop at the Old Town Burial Ground. The first town burying ground, this cemetery was constructed in 1663 and last used in 1939. Most of Sandwich's earliest families are buried here.

Gravestones dating back to the 1600s remind us of the lives lived and the sacrifices made by those in Sandwich's foundations. Walking among them invites quiet reflection on history's enduring lessons.

Town Hall

Nearby, the Town Hall at 130 Main Street, constructed in 1834, serves as a vital historical landmark that brings the community together. The First Parish Meetinghouse, located at what is now 143 Main Street, functioned as the religious and political hub of Sandwich village into the early 19th century. However, the need for a new civic building arose due to the formal separation of church and state. During the 1834 Town Meeting, the town decided to build a new Town Hall at the junction of Main and Grove Streets on marshland donated by the Newcomb family at 8 Grove Street.

Construction began after extensive filling of the marshy land with gravel. The large building featured an upper hall that could seat 500 people, where town meetings were held. Initially, the upper level was accessed by stairways in the front corners of the building from the external front porch.

In 1912, the word SANDWICH was added above TOWN HALL on the building's front (see old postcard of Town Hall with bunting). In 1914, a fourteen-foot extension was added to the south end, which included a stage and dressing rooms, highlighting the upper hall’s role in theatrical productions and later, movies.

Over the years, various parts of the ground floor housed stores, carpenter shops, a newspaper printing office, the library, and early Historical Society offices. Eventually, as the town's circumstances changed, town administrative offices occupied the first floor, and the second-floor ballroom was used for attic storage.

In 2009, the entire building was restored to its former splendor. The second-floor ballroom is particularly striking with its historically accurate stenciling in tan and brown paint and gold leaf, theatrical stage, balcony seating, and fully restored historic shuttered windows. In 2011, the Sandwich Town Hall received a Preservation Award for Rehabilitation & Restoration from the Massachusetts Historical Commission. By 2023, the town decided to relocate its offices to a new site down the street and the building has been occupied by the Sandwich Arts Alliance.

Drinking Fountain

Located between the peaceful surroundings of the Dexter Grist Mill and the white pillars of Sandwich Town Hall is a natural spring drinking fountain, with origins predating the settlement of the oldest town on Cape Cod. The water flows from an artesian well, which operates without the need for pumping because pressure surrounding the water forces it up through the ground continually. The well produces over 12 million gallons of fresh spring water annually.

Although some attribute magical properties to the water, most people fill their jugs because they believe it tastes better than any other water. It's free so fill up a bottle and see for yourself!

Dexter Grist Mill

Adjacent to the Town Hall is the Dexter Grist Mill is a great spot to learn about the agricultural and trade history that shaped Sandwich.The original grist mill was built in 1637 by Thomas Dexter and replaced in 1654. It had the vital purpose of grinding corn into flour for essential baking needs. The Shawme pond was dammed up to create the power source for the grinding wheel. The water is fed by an underground stream that forms a creek which leads into the ocean. This creek provides for the return of the herring each spring. The mill was restored in 1961

The mill is still working today! Make sure to visit on a day they are open to see the process.

Historic Dexter Grist Mill still functioning today.

Deacon Eldred House

The next stop on the tour is the Deacon Eldred House property located at 4 Water Street. The Deacon Eldred House is a two-story, three-quarter colonial home, built in 1756, and was a residential home until 1976, according to Ralph Vitacco, Sandwich director of planning and economic development.

Built over an earlier structure from 1643 by the Tobey family, the house served as the Thornton Burgess Museum from 1974 to 2013. The museum focused on the life and work of Thornton Burgess. Burgess, born in Sandwich, was a conservationist and children's story author. His grandfather, Thomas Burgess, was among the first settlers of Sandwich in 1637, according to the town of Sandwich website. Burgess, a prominent author known for his nature-themed writings, significantly influenced the town’s literary and ecological heritage.

In 2023, the house underwent extensive renovations and is now available for rent as a B&B. The Deacon Eldred home's restoration by Jenny Lee MacDonald and Michael Lemieux of Full Circle Homes was featured on their HGTV show “Houses with History.” The renovation story of the Deacon Eldred House is part of “Season 2, Episode 7 – THE ONE WITH PETER COTTONTAIL.

Hoxie House

Nearby, the Hoxie House at 18 Water Street enriches the historical experience by providing a tangible insight into the lives of early settlers. The Hoxie House, built in 1675, is a saltbox house. According to the Massachusetts Historical Commission, it is the oldest surviving house "in the area".The residence was owned by both the Smith and Hoxie families before being transferred to the town of Sandwich in 1959.

Rev. John Smith, along with his wife Susanna and their 13 children, lived in this location. From 1673 to 1689, Smith was the pastor of the Separatist First Church of Sandwich. Additionally, he was a legislative representative and advocated for tolerance towards the Quakers, who were a religious minority in the region. You might recognize his name from the Salem Witch Trials.

In 1857, Abraham Hoxie, a whaling captain, purchased the property. The town of Sandwich acquired the home in the 1950s and restored the building which now serves as a museum. While you're visting the property make sure to take in the beautiful sights of Shawme Pond.

Your Adventure Awaits

From charming tea rooms to historic churches and serene parks, Sandwich, MA, offers an incredible journey through time. Each site along our tour tells a story, inviting visitors to connect with the rich history of this remarkable town.

Whether you’re a history enthusiast, an architecture lover, or simply seeking a peaceful day out, Sandwich is filled with treasures waiting to be discovered. When you find yourself in the area, take the time to explore the hidden gems of Sandwich—your adventure awaits!

Happy exploring!